In consumer finance, the loyalty penalty is a familiar idea: the extra you pay simply for staying put while new customers are offered better terms. The Financial Conduct Authority took it seriously enough to ban the practice in home and motor insurance from January 2022, after finding that millions of loyal customers were collectively losing more than a billion pounds a year. The same dynamic exists in business lending, and there is no regulator stepping in to fix it for you. Many UK businesses are paying more than they need to on their facilities for one reason only: they have not tested the market since they last borrowed. If that might be you, the short answer is yes, it is worth looking, because both the market and your own business have almost certainly moved on since the deal was struck.
This is not about disloyalty, and it is not a sign that anything is wrong. It is simply that a facility agreed two, three or four years ago was priced for a different business in a different market. If your covenants are tightening, your facility no longer fits, or you are still carrying debt from the CBILS or Recovery Loan Scheme era, those are all signs the question is worth asking. This piece is narrow: it is about whether you are quietly overpaying, and how to find out.
The loyalty penalty is the gap between what an existing customer pays and what the same provider, or the wider market, would offer a new one. It was the focus of a 2018 super-complaint covering markets from mortgages to savings, and it has shaped financial regulation ever since. The logic is simple: pricing drifts upward, or fails to drift downward, for customers who do not shop around, because there is no commercial pressure on the provider to pass on a better deal to someone who is not asking for one.
Business debt is not regulated in the same way as consumer insurance, but the same incentives are at work. An incumbent lender has little reason to proactively cut your margin, extend your facility or loosen a covenant if you have not asked and are not looking elsewhere. Meanwhile, the rate you were given was set against your risk profile and the market conditions at the time. If the business has grown, strengthened its balance sheet or built an asset base since then, and if the lending market has become more competitive, the terms that were fair when you signed may now be well off the pace. The penalty is the difference, and on a seven-figure facility, it is rarely trivial.
Two things change after a facility is agreed, and both tend to work in the borrower's favour over time, if they act on them.
The first is the business itself. A company that has grown its earnings, improved its margins or accumulated assets such as receivables, stock or equipment is, by definition, a better credit risk than it was when it first borrowed. Lenders price risk, so a stronger business should command better terms. But that repricing does not happen automatically; it happens when the business goes and asks for it.
The second is the market. The UK lending landscape has broadened considerably. Where a business once had a relationship bank and little else, funding now spans clearing banks, challenger and specialist banks, asset-based lenders, private credit and debt funds, and fintech lenders. According to the British Business Bank's Small Business Finance Markets report, challenger and specialist banks accounted for 60% of gross SME bank lending in 2025, with challenger banks and non-bank lenders together providing more than two-thirds of all SME lending. That is a very different market from the one most existing facilities were arranged in, and the competition it creates is exactly what a borrower can use. The one complication runs the other way: the rises in the Bank of England base rate have lifted the floor under pricing, which makes it more important, not less, to be sure your margin over that floor is still competitive.
A few signals suggest the loyalty penalty may be at work in your facility. Anyone is worth a second look; more than one is worth a conversation.
None of these confirms you are overpaying. What they confirm is that you do not currently know whether you are, which is the position that the loyalty penalty depends on.
Finding out whether you are overpaying is a benchmarking exercise, and it is more than a rate comparison. The things worth testing against the current market are:
You can do much of this in-house if you have the time, the current market knowledge and the lender relationships. Where it gets harder is the last point, because seeing the whole market and getting lenders to put forward their best terms is a specialist exercise.
If the benchmarking shows a gap, closing it usually means refinancing: replacing the existing facility with a better one, or asking the incumbent to match what the market will offer. Often, the mere fact of running a competitive process is enough to improve the incumbent's terms, because a lender that knows it is being benchmarked behaves differently from one that assumes you are staying put.
It is worth being clear that this is routine, not adversarial. Testing the market is ordinary financial management, and a well-run refinancing is relationship-preserving rather than relationship-ending. There are real mechanics to it, and the process, the costs and the timing all matter, but the point here is simply that the remedy for a loyalty penalty is to act on it, and that acting on it is normal.
Here is the catch with checking whether you are overpaying: most of the people you could ask have a stake in the answer. Your incumbent lender will only ever offer its own products. A broker may work from a limited panel or be paid by the lenders it places business with. Neither is well placed to give you a genuinely neutral read on whether your current deal still stacks up.
This is where independence matters. An independent adviser that takes no fees from lenders has no reason to point you anywhere other than the best available outcome. That is the whole basis on which FBX works: whole-of-market, paid by the business rather than the lender, and therefore free to tell you honestly whether your current terms are competitive or not, even if the answer is that they are. An honest benchmark from someone with no product to sell is worth more than a dozen renewal letters from a lender with every reason to keep you where you are.
It depends entirely on the gap between your current terms and the market, which is why benchmarking comes first. Sometimes the saving is substantial; sometimes your existing deal turns out to be competitive and the right answer is to stay. The only way to know is to look, and a competitive process often improves your incumbent's terms even if you do not move.
You can review your margin, fees, structure and covenants in-house, which will tell you whether the facility looks dated. What you cannot do from the inside is see what every other lender would offer, which is the part that confirms whether a gap exists. That is where whole-of-market reach adds value.